A Grade Ahead Reviews the Book Versus the Movie: Goosebumps

For many, R.L. Stine’s Goosebumps books have a special place in their heart, especially for those who grew up in the early 1990s. In 1992, Stine started publishing the fiction series, and he would go on to write 156 Goosebumps books with creepy stories, monsters, and surprise endings; the series became a favorite for kids who love a good scare.

At A Grade Ahead, we love exploring fiction in our enrichment classes for English students. Call or visit an A Grade Ahead academy near you to get a free curriculum sample, take a free assessment, or sign up for a free trial class today!

 

Stine’s stories were so popular that they didn’t just stay on the page! The 2015 film, its 2018 follow-up, and a brand-new Disney+ TV series (2023) all brought Goosebumps to life. However, the television series and films combine elements from multiple books to create new adventures rather than focusing on a single book at a time.

Let’s examine some of the books that were adapted for the screen and how the tales were somewhat altered!

The Haunted Mask (1993)

In the book, the Halloween mask that Carly Beth wears begins to control her personality. The mask is one of several eerie objects that come to life in the film.

Difference: The film transforms the tale into a grand, thrilling journey, but the book focuses more on bravery and identity.

Night of the Living Dummy (1993)

One of the most well-known villains from Goosebumps is Slappy, the malevolent dummy. He causes problems for families in the books. He is the primary antagonist who gives life to all of the monsters in the film.

Difference: Slappy is the leader of the mayhem in the film rather than just one terrifying tale!

Monster Blood (1992)

Anything that comes into contact with this green slime gets bigger and bigger. It turns into one of the most dangerous monsters in the film.

Difference: The suspense in the book is slow and eerie, while the film makes it quick, humorous, and action-packed.

A Shocker on Shock Street (1995)

Children tour a theme park in the book where animated creatures from movies come to life. That concept is also used in the film, which depicts monsters fleeing from R.L. Stine’s works.

Difference: The film focuses less on fear and more on fun and imagination.

The Curse of the Mummy’s Tomb (1993)

The book is about a mummy that comes back to life. In the film, the mummy is one of the numerous creatures that are released by Slappy.

Difference: The book is spooky and mysterious, while the movie makes it part of a big, exciting adventure.

The Werewolf of Fever Swamp (1993)

In the book, a boy thinks his dog might be a werewolf. In the movie, the werewolf is just one of many monsters chasing the main characters.

Difference: The movie swaps quiet mystery for fast, funny action.

Say Cheese and Die (1992)

This story is about a camera that captures bad things happening in its pictures. The movie includes the creepy camera as one of the items that causes problems.

Difference: The book is slow and mysterious, but the movie uses it for quick, exciting moments.

Attack of the Mutant (1994)

A child discovers that the villain and hero he loves in comic books are real. That concept is used in the film to illustrate how R.L. Stine’s stories come to life.

Difference: The movie integrates the ideas from Goosebumps books into the larger Goosebumps universe, whereas the book is a single child’s experience.

Overall Thoughts

The Films

The Goosebumps movies mix together many horror stories instead of retelling just one book. They have more humor, and they are filled with action.  Generally, the books are scarier and concentrate more on the emotions and fears of the characters. The film maintains its core message: it’s okay to face your fears and use imagination and teamwork to do so.

The Disney+ Series

Using inspiration from classic books such as Say Cheese and Die! and Night of the Living Dummy, the 2023 Disney+ Goosebumps series delivers new scares for a new generation. For the audience of today, it blends mystery, camaraderie, and eerie enjoyment.

Though a bit darker than the films, the program is nonetheless exciting and full of adventure. It’s a fantastic method for new fans to learn about Goosebumps!

Did you know that A Grade Ahead begins exploring the idea of compare and contrast as early as 4th grade? Ask about our programs today!

Final Thoughts

Goosebumps never stops coming up with new ways to frighten and amuse families through books, movies, or streaming TV. Goosebumps demonstrates that horror can also be a lot of fun, whether you enjoy reading about Slappy’s tricks, watching the green slime build, or speculating about what will happen next.

What do you think? Have you read or watched Goosebumps? What is your favorite story? Do you prefer reading or watching the tales unfold? Let us know which book-turned-movie we should explore next in the comments!

 

Author: Pamela Crum, Teacher Coordinator at A Grade Ahead

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *