20,000 Leagues Under the Sea – Exploring the Depths
Recently, A Grade Ahead 6th Grade English enrichment classes explored science fiction writing. As a tribute to Sci-Fi fans, I decided to choose a book versus the movie that both highlights the genre’s unique features and is also a timeless classic.
Background
Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea is a literary voyage of science fiction, imagination, and philosophy, while the film adaptations—particularly the classic 1954 Disney version—translate that journey into a vivid, visual spectacle. Both the book and the movie take audiences deep beneath the ocean’s surface aboard the Nautilus but use distinct methods to create the setting and express tone.
Imagery
In Verne’s novel, the imagery is created through rich, descriptive language. Verne paints the world underneath the sea with scientific precision and poetic words describing its beauty, letting readers picture glowing jellyfish, sunken cities, and coral reefs. The unknown depths of the sea provide wondrous and eerie marvels that challenge imagination through the carefully chosen words of Jules Verne.
In contrast, the film adaptation offers visual imagery that immediately captures the audience’s attention. The iconic look of the Nautilus, the deep-sea diving suits, and the menacing giant squid bring Verne’s world to life. The color, lighting, and underwater effects of the 1954 movie create a distinct mood: mysterious, tense, and sometimes fantastical. While the film does not explore every detail from the book, its imagery helps the audience experience the undersea adventure in a more direct, sensory way.
Tone
The tone of the book leans heavily into curiosity, wonder, and philosophical questioning. Captain Nemo is portrayed as a complex, often tragic figure driven by loss, a thirst for knowledge, and sometimes revenge. The tone is thoughtful, sometimes somber, as the narrative reflects on humanity, nature, and the cost of obsession.
The movie, on the other hand, is more adventurous and dramatic in tone. It simplifies some of the moral dilemmas Nemo faces and emphasizes action. There’s suspense and excitement, but less focus on the deeper moral and philosophical questions raised in the novel. The result is a visual cinematic experience that appeals to all ages.
Conclusion
In comparing the two, it’s clear that each has its strengths: the book dives deeper into ideas, while the movie immerses us in sights and sounds. Together, they offer two ways to experience the same timeless journey—one through the mind’s eye, and the other through the lens of film.
What do you think? Have you read or watched 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea? Do you prefer the book or the movie? Let us know which book-turned-movie we should explore next in the comments!
Looking for even more? Call or visit one of our academies nationwide to learn about what we can offer you! Why wait to start your child’s educational adventure?
Author: Pamela Crum, Teacher Coordinator at A Grade Ahead
